Reviews for The Essential Guide to
Irish Flute and Tin Whistle
"Grey has, through his research, patience, and diligence, completed
a work on Irish flute and tin whistle that I feel is essential reading
for anybody interested in getting it right.”
- Matt Molloy, flute player with The Bothy Band and
The Chieftains
"Holy sweet Moses, Grey. Absolutely unbelievable. Obviously, I haven't
been able to do anything other than look through it. But, it is scholarly,
beautifully written, loaded with fabulous pictures and and diagrams. Nothing,
and I mean nothing, approaches it in any of the tutors. And the idea of
combining the flute & whistle this way is a real innovation. This
is a triumph. Grey Larsen, if this weren't already guaranteed, has just
earned his place in Irish Trad history."
- Dale Wisely, Chiff and Fipple
"Got the book! Looks terrific, sounds good, too! Will take a while
to wade through it all the way! Best of luck getting it out and about!
- LE McCullough, author of The Complete Tin Whistle Tutor
"Grey writes with great clarity, saying the most in the fewest words
possible. This is the most important work on the traditional flute to
appear in over 150 years ... 'required reading' for the Irish flute playing
community, and as well for the Irish music community at large..."
- Casey Burns, Casey Burns Flutes
"The Essential Guide to Irish Flute and Tin Whistle is
a momentous body of work. It is a large book consisting of 480 pages and
two companion CDs including 27 meticulous transcriptions of recordings
from 1926 to 2001. The title is apt; a good teacher notwithstanding-,
this book is clearly “essential” for anyone looking to learn
or improve on his or her technique in playing Irish Music on the Flute
or Whistle.
"I personally view this body of work as the first and only complete
Irish Flute treatise. This treatise advances a clear and concise understanding
of the styles of Flute and Whistle used in the playing of Irish traditional
music. Irish Flute player, Grey Larsen, began to formulate the ideas and
concepts set forth in this book over the course of many years. The kind
of energy invested into a book of this size and scope does not come quickly,
it requires many years of playing, teaching, and being steeped in the
tradition. Grey Larsen is not only a wonderful musician, but a good teacher
and communicator as well. For all of the students of the Irish Flute and
Whistle, from beginner to advanced, the wait for a definitive text is
over. I don’t believe we’ll ever see another book written
with this amount of insight, deliberation, and attention to detail. This
kind of diligent work will live on for many long years to come."
- Steve Cox, Tallgrass Winds
"Grey, your book arrived today - in record time!! What a tome!!
Excellently presented, and having dipped into a few of the chapters at
random I know I will be using it as a resource for years to come in the
teaching of ornamentation and many other general aspects of Irish music.
Congratulations."
- Garry Shannon, Ireland
"Grey - I just started Chapter Six and wanted to drop you a line.
So far, this appears to be the very best, most comprehensive, focused
and well-explained book I've seen in this area. Although the only real
new information I gleaned from the first five chapters was the section
on Irish trad musical modes and some of the history of flutes, the rest
nevertheless served as tremendous reaffirmation and focused what learning
and experience I already have. This is indeed the perfect must-have reference
for one who also comes to this music as an outsider (although you are
certainly no longer an 'outsider.') This is very well-written and presented
in clear and concise terms and logically. Chapter Six is perfect for me
as I am now considering taking up flute in addition to whistle. Perhaps
you will demystify the transverse embouchure for me and highlight the
additional joys of flute playing.
"In sum, a great work for all, including and perhaps particularly
beginners. I read music and have been playing whistle for years and am
still in search of some mastery of that 'lilt' that you and teacher Bill
Ochs refer to. I've seen some comment on C&F [chiffandfipple.com]
that the book is perhaps not good for beginners who haven't yet learned
to read music. I disagree. There is so much pivotal info re the really
important approach to the instrument and music that I simply can't imagine
any beginner not taking advantage of this work.
"I look forward to the ornamentation section because you just happen
to explain things in a way that is easy for me to intake (we each take
in learning differently).
"Terrific job. Thanks again."
- Phil Osattin
"Grey Larsen heeft bereikt wat - tot nu toe - onmogelijk leek:
het leren spelen van Ierse traditionele muziek op fluit en whistle zonder
hulp van een leraar! Tijdens mijn vijfentwintigjarige loopbaan als fluitdocent
heb ik al aardig wat methodes onder ogen gehad. Geen van hen waren zó
omvangrijk, diepgravend en toch gemakkelijk te begrijpen. The Essential
Guide to Irish Flute and Tin Whistle is een juweel."
English translation:
"Grey Larsen has achieved something that - until now - seemed impossible:
learning to play Irish traditional music on flute and whistle without
the presence of a teacher! During my twenty-five year career as a flute
teacher I've seen quite a few methods. None of them were as extensive,
profound, and comprehensive as this book is. The Essential Guide to
Irish Flute and Tin Whistle is a gem."
- Bart Wijnen, Leeuwarden, the Netherlands
"The book is fantastic and I am excited about delving into it (Kate
[Chris' wife] thought you must have been a university professor to have
written such an all encompassing work.) I still think there is a place
for you somewhere as a professor - you already have your text-book and
credentials as a player and teacher (Have Book, Will Teach)."
- Chris Abell, Abell Flute Company
"Looking forward to the book and cd's. I can't believe you can
offer it at that price. I paid $40.00 for a cd-room tutor with no book
last year only on the whistle.
"I'm continuing to go through the book and find it just full of
great information. One of my favorite parts is the section on each player
you have transcribed. Just great to get a sense of who these great players
are, and in some cases were."
-Stephen Brown
"The hardcore traditionalists reckon the only way to learn ITM is
to immerse yourself entirely in the music and the culture. Maybe they're
right, I don't know, but I live thousands and thousands of miles away
from the nearest hotbed of Irish culture, so that ain't gonna happen.
Fortunately with Grey's new book, previously impenetrable mysteries of
Irish fluting have opened themselves up to me, and together with a lot
of listening my playing has improved in leaps and bounds in the few months
since I received the book. Tome, I should say. In particular, Grey's examination
of ornamentation, and the new notation system he's developed to describe
ornamentation, have been invaluable to my whistling and flootin'. I look
forward to future publications using this notation system, whether they're
further analyses of the playing of the pro's, or tune-learning guides.
Landmark stuff."
- Matthew Du Plessis, South Africa
"Mi è arrivato oggi il libro di di Grey Larsen ,se tutto
quello che promette nell'introduzione è vero ,sarà un calvario
di delizie."
English translation:
"Today Grey Larsen's book arrived. If everything written in the
preface and in the introduction is true, it will be a 'Calvary of delights.'"
- Stefano Zucchi, Italy
"Grey, I just wanted to let you know that I'm very pleased with
your Essential Guide to Irish Flute and Tin Whistle. The title
for this book is certainly apt. It is indeed an 'essential' book for anyone
wanting to learn to play the Irish flute and tin whistle. I was especially
appreciative of the chapters on cuts and rolls. Your explanation of the
timing and rhythm for this ornamentation was a real epiphany for me. To
be honest, I'd given up on playing tin whistle, not to mention even attempting
the flute. But your book has inspired me to give it another go and to
stick with it."
- Greg Laing
"I just wanted to send a note of thanks and congratulations your
way...your new book is absolutely fantastic! I've been playing Irish music
for about two years (having come from 15 years of classical flute playing),
and already within two weeks of owning (and voraciously reading) your
book, aspects of my playing have begun to improve, and my awareness of
various elements of my playing and of Irish music has increased.
"So thank you for this wonderful gift to the music community, and
congratulations on a most marvelous testimony to your musicality and teaching
abilities."
- M.S., Wisconsin
"Got the book. WOW!! I had no idea that you had made something
so comprehensive. This is just what I've been looking for for quite some
time.
"Gotta run, holidays and all that, but I think I'm going to be in
a room away from the family with your book and the other prize that showed
up today: my Olwell blackwood six key. Yes, they did show up at the same
time.
"I should say that I have been living with [your book] since it's
arrival and, as a sign that it is well used, it now can stay open on my
music stand without any 'secondary weights' holding the pages open. I
have learnt many a thing, and have RELEARNED many more. BRAVO!"
- Dave Weiss, NYC Studio Musician
"The first of the books I ordered arrived today. It's super! Thanks
for turning out such a great resource, Grey. Thanks as well for using
the female third person singular. As a linguist and English teacher, the
overuse of the 'generic' male (when research tests show over and over
again that it's clearly not neutral) has long perturbed me."
- Tommy Kochel, Harrisburg Area Community College
"The book, by the way, is FABULOUS; you've done a marvelous job,
and I am looking forward to spending a lot of time exploring its pages
in the days/weeks/months (years?) to come!
"It's a HUGE thing you have done, and you have my sincere 'Attaboy!'
(or, in keeping with the book itself, my sincere 'attagirl!') for your
effort. Bravo!!! May this book of yours bring you both monetary and spiritual
riches untold!"
- Rebecca Deryckx
"I have received The Book and whew! I've dived in already! Thank
you, thank you, thank you for such a comprehensive compilation of comparative
composition that I hope to comprehend. :-)"
- Judi Stewart
"I've just gotten my copy of your new book, it is excellent. It
helped me immediately resolve a problem I was having with my flute grip."
- Mark Thompson, woodwinds and pipes for the Burnt Haggis
Band
"This is a really astounding work which I think will benefit Celtic
wind players hugely. I think your new notation for ornaments makes a world
of sense. I came to whistle via classical music (my wife and I remain
avid recorder players) and it truly does not make sense to use the classical
notation to write out Celtic ornaments. I looked briefly at your discussion
of cuts which is terrific. If that teaches people to play this ubiquitous
ornament as a mere interruption of or between notes, rather than as a
discrete note, that alone would be worth the price of the book. I suspect
the rest of the book will be similarly insightful. More after I delve
deeper...."
- Paul Busman
"I just got your new book and it is a great addition to the history
of the instrument. I will be back after the holidays to get another book
for my nephew. Thank you for your hard word and inspiration!!"
- Laura Monagle
"Grey: arrived today! already can tell its an incredible piece
of work.... looking forward to learning from it and also want to use it
to explain stuff to others..."
- Tim Smith
"There's no substitute for hearing how something should be played,
no matter how good the explanation, so the CDs are a great addition to
the book."
- Claire Farra
"I have your new book on the Flute & Tin Whistle --
Wonderful effort! Thanks for writing this. I ... am diligently working
on embouchure. Once I get a little more advanced, this well help tremendously.
"I'm looking forward to The Essential Tin Whistle Toolbox."
- Dan McFeeley
"I consult the Chiffandfipple web site from time to time, and saw
your book advertised, as well as knowing about your flute exploits. I'm
an Irishman and started the flute and whistle about a year and half ago
and need good resources, as there are no Irish flute teachers here in
China. I take courses through Scoiltrad but also need a good book that
is comprehensive on all aspects."
- John McCormack
"Wish you an outstanding Christmas and New Year. As we say in india,
your stars are shining bright these days with the new ground-breaking
book and new CD."
- Greg Collins, India
"I just purchased The Essential Guide to Irish Flute and Tin
Whistle, am only about 1/3 of the way through, and am totally entranced.
This is a great book! I am a tin whistle newbie, but not to music (trumpet,
guitar for many years).
"I have been teaching myself from the material that was packaged
with the whistle I bought and was having some fun, until I got this book.
It just opened up sooooo much more to me on so many levels.
"The book is written well and flows logically and smoothly. It has
tons of detail and pictures, right down to how to sit and how to hold
the whistle (...I needed that). It also has tons of exercise and song
transcriptions. But it is still real easy to navigate through all the
detail you may not need.
"The CDs add a 3rd dimension to the package and really help to flesh
out the real thing, in addition to all the fine historical and cultural
info.
"I can't say enough good about the book. It's the complete package
and the real deal."
- Fred, Austin, Texas
"I received the book on Tuesday, and I'm very, very impressed with
it. Thank you very much for an amazing piece of work.
"I'm self-taught on the flute and pennywhistle, and I really appreciate
this book's detailed step-by-step instructions on every aspect of technique.
The depth and breadth of this work really do make it 'essential' for any
player who's interested in moving to the next level of playing Irish traditional
music. And the historical background and discussion of controversies are
enlightening for those who like to understand what they're hearing and
doing."
- Mitch Imhoff
"You have created an important, monumental work. I am unaware of
any other treatise for any instrument that so accurately and clearly deconstructs
an entire musical idiom. I find your fully notated tunes including ornaments,
articulations, breath pauses and alternate phrasings particularly useful."
- Robert Yarbrough
"The first few chapters, in which Larsen covers the basics of Irish
traditional music, are required reading for anyone wanting to participate
in this musical culture, especially if not born into it. The rest of the
book is a must have for fluters and whistlers, and will also prove extremely
helpful to Uilleann pipers. There hasn't been as thorough an examination
of how Irish music works, from any perspective. He introduces a new, clear
way of notating tunes that will become the standard. As technical and
scholarly as the content is, Larsen is never dry or academic. The two
CDs are an added bonus.
"Five stars. Excellent, and not just for fluters."
- An Amazon.com customer from Burton, Washington, United States,
March 8, 2004
Reviews for The Essential Tin
Whistle Toolbox
“An essential set of tools for the beginning and intermediate
tin whistle player. I highly recommend it!”
- Joanie Madden, whistle and flute player with Cherish the
Ladies